小知识

屏幕截图

视频

评论来自 filtr

Heroic mode is pretty tough and there is a 55 minute time limit to save the npcs that are being executed (Must save them to complete the quest). It's done easily after learning the pulls so probably not your first time through on heroic put should be able to do it the 2nd or 3rd try.

评论来自 MasterThelps

Any suggestions on good group setups for Heroic? Especially in view of completing this quest.

评论来自 tjtobin

Just curious, but where in the instance is the executioner? I assume he isn't a boss, but I would imagine he is way at the end though.

评论来自 24057

It is the last boss, Kargath, that is "the executioner", kill him on heroic :) GL, downed once by nihilum.. no one else on magtheridon I believe

评论来自 24541

It should be stated that the 55-minute countdown does not start until you go through the second door in the Grand Warlock's room. That is to say, once you kill the Grand Warlock (1st boss), and leave his room to continue onward, you receive a debuff - similar to 45 Baron runs - that shows you how much time you have remaining.

评论来自 21638

Somehow i manage to abandon this quest from A'dal, is there any possible way to get it back?

评论来自 28473

and generally how you start this quests?A'dal doesnt give another quest after the key to the arcatraz!so, what do we have to do?

评论来自 30095

Superberit, i don't think nihilum are the only ones who did full shattered hall in heroic. I did it 2-3 weeks ago with my guild (Vanquish), but we killed the last boss after 2 prisoners were down, so we didn't complete the quest :(

评论来自 blckA

I did a heroic run today and we were 5 minutes overdue of the timer.
One prisoner got slain but surprisingly enough the executioner did drop the quest item.

评论来自 Farshid

Did this a few days ago and we were overdue since we wiped a few times on O'mrogg (ogre boss).

We missed the first two prisoners but were able to kill Kargath before the third prisoner died and we still completed the quest. I think you got the first 55 minutes, and 15 extra minutes per prisoner (there are 3 prisoners in total, second one being for this quest: http://www.wowhead.com/?quest=9524).

评论来自 Izichial

When you kill Kargath on heroic, a Shattered Hand Executioner and the prisoners spawn in the small area after Kargath's. This npc drops the Unused Axe of the Executioner. The quest NPC for the 'Imprisoned in the Citadel' also spawns here, being one of the prisoners.

评论来自 37059

I have learned why I was not able to receive the quest item on my first successful run and let it be a tip/warning to all of you who are still on the quest:

Blizzard has it programmed in heroics that if at any time there are more than 5 people in the instance, all quest items that would normally drop in the instance will not drop. In my case, one of our members lost his internet connection and could not log back on and we had to replace him. However, people who DC'ed or logged inside the instance counts toward that 5 person limit.

Therefore, be wary if a party member DC's, or if you're clearing the instance and switching out before the executioner to help friends get attuned to not let any additional people zone in until there is space for them in the zone.

评论来自 14992

Pretty hard quest , our guild is curently at Maghteridon and we are doing the Trials , we were flasked and poted and Cleared it without any major problems , thou only third prisoner was alive :)
Good luck in doing it !

评论来自 47614

Finished it first try with 12 minutes left on the timer before the first prisoner was due to be killed. Just one death (the priest), the entire run. Only one of us had been in a heroic SH before.

Group was an arcane/frost mage, feral druid, disc/holy priest, destruction warlock and a ret/holy paladin.

Trickiest bit for us were the pulls in the hallway between the centurions, other than that it was all pretty trivial; including the last boss.

My advice to anyone trying this is to take as much CC and as little melee as possible.

评论来自 12394

Group: Warrior, Holy Priest (me), Shadow Priest, Mage and Rogue. The hardest fight was Kargath due to squishiness, but we managed on the third attempt. All other boss fights went smooth, trash is the real killer in this instance.

评论来自 sanafey

We finished it with i dunno how much minutes left. but we had 21 on timer after 2nd boss.

Destruction lock, feral druid(me), retro/holy paladin, arcane/frost mage and a shadow priest.

Really nice damage but all very well geared (kara /tier4 at least). We wiped several times before first boss on the big elite packs. Luckily we had sheep, fear, frost nova etc. And our healer didnt die in one hit.

We skipped the groups with centurions, pulling only the centered mobs and dogpatrols way back in the first room to chain fear them.

We wiped 1x during timer on Kargath cause the dps (3xcloth) just got nuked by adds and whirlwind. Second try i positioned boss in left corner while paladin was in leftuppercorner, and the rest on other side. Well spread out and far away so the whirlwind ran out by the time it arrived at them. The adds were sheeped, feared etc.

All 3 prisoners were still alive :D

Hardest packs (3 packs plus one big one) r before first boss but you can take your time on them. And the miniboss (he cleaves) and the ones with the centurion packs on de the sides (2 packs)

评论来自 anthrt

Why is there a screenshot of the AV NPCs on here? What relevance does it hold?

评论来自 23096

Ran the instance with Feral Druid, Fire Mage, Affliction Lock, Holy Paladin, Holy Paladin. Took us at least 90 minutes to clear the whole thing. I can confirm that you can get the quest item after 2 npc's have been executed. After he killed one we got a 10 minute debuff. After he killed the second one we got a 15 minute debuff. Tips for clearing are watch out for assassin after the first boss while clearing through the hallway full of archers and spawns. The 2nd boss with 2 archers is simple to kill and his adds are pretty weak if you want to kill them first. Don't rush yourselves into a wipe, because theres a enough time for a slow steady clear.

评论来自 60976

Completed very easily with this group:

Protection Paladin
Holy Paladin
Resto Druid
Affliction Warlock
Fire Mage

Bascially used no CC, had the paladin aoe tank the entire groups while the warlock and mage aoe'd them down. With 2 healers it was no problem keeping the tank up. Our gear was mostly blues with a few karazhan epics but nothing major.

Took the first section at a reasonable pace, since the timer only starts after the first boss. Nethercurse was definately the hardest part of the run for us but we only wiped once. Deathcoil is a pain since it seemed to only hit our tank, but running towards wherever the tank is feared to made it not too much of an issue. Void zones really hurt on heroic so everyone needs to be alert.

Continued on after him with still a steady pace, drinking between each pull etc. Reached 2nd boss with plenty of time using this aoe tactic and had no trouble killing him. Just be sure that the person who gets aggro after a switch does not do anything, and keep them spam healed. Boss seemed to hit for 4k on cloth so not too hard keeping even the mage alive.

For the last boss we all stood on the steps, apart from the tank who stood in the middle of Kargaths room, had the warlock on Kargath while the druid and mage took care of the adds (Druid in some balance gear). Killed him with 16 minutes left on timer, all 3 prisoners still alive.

Dont rush things and you should have no problem.

评论来自 60495

When I ran this, we wiped so many times that the timer ran out before the second boss - but the timer popped up again by the time we had reached kargath.

We didn't kill him in time because assassins kept aggroing (don't ask) but I was wondering if the quest could have been completed? Perhaps if someone else has the misfortune to go through an equally agonizing run they can see if this works.

评论来自 Affekted

ive tried this 2 times we always get stuck after first boss and in hallway on teh way to porung. the tanks agro just doesnt build up at all on the adds. group is
prot war/hunter mm/ice mage/lock/holy priest
all in tier 4 about 3/5 and kara - gruuls gear and they always go and 1 shot the healer or w/e and the tank just not getting agro on the mobs through that stretch which is really stupid is this a bug or happen for everyone?

评论来自 Megami

Prot War, Fire Mage, Hunter, Aff Warlock, Holy Priest

Sheep, Trap, Seduce, Fear, 2nd Fear if necessary. Easy as hell. Wiped once on the 6+ packs and once on Warbringer O'mrogg (watch dps, dps OFF when he leaves the tank).

评论来自 Navaash

With today's annoucement by Blizzard that there will now be no attunement required to enter The Eye, it is no longer necessary to do this quest:

http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=110637185

However the quest will remain in game; the same post also implies they may add a reward in the future for those who have fully completed this questline.

评论来自 doown

According to http://www.worldofraids.com/#7638 , those who complete this now alost obsolete chain get a nice title for the trouble:

New Title - Champion of the Naaru: Awarded to those who complete the Tempest Keep attunement quest at level 70.

评论来自 40975

If your group fully wipes, is there a way of restarting the timer? Or are you fecked until the reset?

评论来自 79477

Did this a few weeks ago with what I think was a nearly ideal group: 1 well-geared pally tank, 2 healers, 1 DPS warrior, and 1 rogue.

The pally tank was able to do huge group pulls with two healers on him. Since he never ran out of mana, his threat generation was ridiculous, allowing the DPS warrior to AoE his heart out (same with the rogue).

This was the pally's first time tanking and my first time healing SH on heroic.

We were able to kill everything, even with 1 wipe, with around 10 minutes to spare before the first prisoner's death.

From that experience, I'd say that any decently good Tankadin with two healers and some form of AoE should be able to complete this fairly easily.

评论来自 107368

May be a dumb question but no one else said...If you die do you fail the quest??

评论来自 mattattack

It's definitely worth mentioning, that as of patch 2.4.2, after our group wiped a few times (holy pally, BM hunter, prot warrior, shadow priest, and enh shaman), there was only one prisoner left after Kargath was killed and I was still able to complete this quest.

评论来自 Flapalapagus

Not sure why but I also thought that these Trials were after the Arcatraz key quest chain lol. But You have to complete the VERY long quest chain that starts with this in Shadowmoon Valley The Hand of Gul'dan and then you receive these Trials. Also if you complete all 4 of these Trials, Trial of the Naaru: Mercy, Trial of the Naaru: Magtheridon, Trial of the Naaru: Strength, Trial of the Naaru: Tenacity and complete the quest The Cudgel of Kar'desh you get the cool title Champion of the Naaru. The two quest chains mentioned above used to be attunement quests for the Tempest Keep: The Eye, and Serpantshrine Cavern but are no longer required to enter the two raid dungeons. Imo this title is more prestigious than the title Hand of A'dal since Hand of A'dal is a required title to do either Mount Hyjal or Black Temple.

评论来自 Kathucka

The timed event happens on Heroic, regardless of quests.

If you complete it with no prisoners executed, you get a Badge of Justice, some primals, and a big pile of potions.

If one prisoner is executed, you lose the badge.

If two are executed, you lose the primals.

A group today seriously botched the fire archer gauntlet and had an extended wipe as people ran back, but managed to finish the event before losing any primals. With good gear and a paladin tank, it's not too hard. Just make sure that you skip the gladiators.

评论来自 Flapalapagus

The joy of many people (such as myself) will be glad to hear that... Well... Let me tell you in random sentences.

The new unused is used!

In the language that A'dal speaks unused actually means stained with or without blood of the prisoners.

If you don't yet understand what I'm saying... It means you can, despite the quest text and the item you need, you can still get the axe as long as you can save at least 1 prisoner. You can have two of them dead or just one of them dead or none you will STILL get the axe.

评论来自 155144

What happens if you clear the instance in to Kargath, then go out of the instance, pick up the quest, and kill him? Timer should be no problem.

评论来自 232311

http://www.wowwiki.com/Champion_of_the_naaru states that the title <name>, Champion of the Naaru is no longer available to players that are over lvl 70 and is only available to those who took the trials of the Naaru quests before 3.0.2. The world of Warcraft Official site, however, still has it in the roster of possible titles. I'm still trying to confirm whether you can still obtain the title.

评论来自 478970

I completed this as a level 85 shadow priest today. Took me about 25 minutes to do a full clear. However, when I killed Kargath, there were no prisoners behind him at all. I know I did it in heroic mode, and I know I did not exceed the 55 minute deadline. I opened a ticket, but this quest may be bugged at this time.

Edit - December 6: received ticket from GM, quest will be fixed in future patch.

EDIT - April 18 2012: This quest is now working again and can be completed within the aforementioned time parameter.

评论来自 aaglo

I tried to carry out this quest in 4.3, but there was no timer in shattered halls at all.
Could it be because I've saved "the executees" before?

评论来自 LaCrysta

I'm thinking this happened because of the changes to Dungeon quests. Before, there were quests that you received outside the instance, to do things inside; but that was changed so that the outside quests were just breadcrumbs leading you to a questgiver waiting inside the dungeon.

I was working on Shattered Sun Offensive rep during the update, and before I got a quest to go to Magister's Terrace to find the SSO spy; after the update, I got a quest to meet the SSO just inside the instance, and their leader gave me the same quest to find the spy, so I did the whole line twice.

It's possible the trigger to activate the executioner, which is tied to the external quest from A'dal, wasn't recreated with the new internal quest equivalents. So I think it's a bug, not something removed.

* So not liking the new comment system *

评论来自 Taimea

I sent in a in game ticket 3 days ago and was told that this quest has been "half removed" in so much you can get the quest but not complete it so they send in a report to the QA ....so who knows if this quest will be put fully back in or if this part just be removed since i did the last 2 half of the quest chain.

评论来自 364090

Noticed I still had these quests available to me. Hopefully they plan to put the executioner back in at some point.

评论来自 Drael

I couldn't complete it myself and submited a ticket. The GM said that the quest the executioner must be gone because of the Cataclysm and that basically the quest is there and I can't compelte it. He said he couldn't help me complete it because the title/reward was there for people that did it back in the day when it was supposed to be done :/

评论来自 918407

A hotfix was put in so this quest could be completed again.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/blog/4023884

评论来自 andymitchelluk

From a blue post of hotfixes as of today:

Players are now able to complete the quest Trial of the Naaru: Mercy by beating the 55-minute timer.

Source

It's under Dec 20th fixes, literally the last line before Dec 12th's fixes.

评论来自 LaCrysta

The patch notes from Dec 20th said the quest is fixed. Just ran it and it is back to normal.

评论来自 ibroadfo

Just to confirm: I ran this today, the executioner was killable and the quest was successfully completed.

评论来自 Pypode

I've spent too much time trying to get into a place for which there is no key. I haven't seen this anywhere and I have looked for a long time.
If you don't have any rogues or engineers, jump down into the green area. Kill the green sludge-thingys. Run forward a bit until you see a couple of planks leaning against the tunnel wall (on your left). Climb up. Ta-daah! You're in. Follow other advice for fights.

评论来自 526256

Just ran this Quest. at lvl 85 feral druid, ran thru and cleaned up the mobs as they came. after the last boss the timer stops and u continue down the path and the quest boss dropped the quest item. I spent 5 mins on here, after the boss fight and timer stopped, to see where I had to go to complete the quest. I hope this helps resolve some issues I had. have fun and happy gaming

评论来自 Calentor

This quest does not count towards 泰罗卡的恐惧

评论来自 895733

just ran solo through shattered halls just for kicks to complete this quest, no problems, lvl90 hunter. Took 5min with 3 prisoners left...quest complete

评论来自 aenia

Just completed this patch 6.0.2

评论来自 Pyro2678

I went to do this quest with my wife a few days ago, and rather than waiting on a massively long dungeon queue, we each opted to hop onto our mains to help the other on their lowbie. We had an issue where the axe wouldn't drop even on heroic difficulty until we discovered that the person who has the quest HAS to tag the Executioner and participate in the kill in order to obtain his axe. None of the comments we read here told us this info so I am leaving this here for others to find that are having the same issue.

Good luck! :)

评论来自 skyline33

I had completed this in Late TBC/Early WoTLK when you needed keys to enter the dungeons/raids etc

Not sure why or when but I am now able to complete this whole chain again. Not worth it as keys are no longer required

评论来自 exmate

Is it possible, to make this quest solo?. i simply can´t make the dungeon the shattered halls change to heroic, does i really need another person to make that change?. =/

评论来自 IceglowHunter

How do I get A'dal to give me this quest?

链接

纳鲁的试炼：仁慈

沙塔斯城的阿达尔要求你从地狱火堡垒的破碎大厅中取回未使用的刽子手之斧。

该任务必须在英雄等级难度的地下城中完成。

	未使用的刽子手之斧（1）

描述

想要证明你自己拥有获得风暴钥匙的资格，你必须首先完成四个试炼。

近日里，有三名你的同族被囚禁在地狱火堡垒的破碎大厅中。他们被残忍无情的卡加斯·拳刃所逮捕，很快就要被他以展示力量与气概为由处死。你必须在这场暴行发生之前将这些可怜的囚徒拯救出来。你要带回刽子手还未来得及使用的斩首斧作为证据。斧刃上不能有一滴鲜血存在！

奖励

您会收到：

收获

完成任务后，你将获得：

500 点沙塔尔声望

输入以下代码查看此任务是否已完成

/run print(C_QuestLog.IsQuestFlaggedCompleted(10884))

纳鲁的试炼：仁慈

描述

奖励

收获

相关

贡献